Press Releases

For Immediate Release                                                                                                           Contact: Michael J. McQuerry

October 16, 2019                                                                                                                            202-215-8524

PRESS STATEMENT

CONGRESSWOMAN STACEY PLASKETT RELEASES STATEMENT ON SUPREME COURT CASE RELATED TO THE INSULAR CASES

“Jessica Mendez Colberg, a young Puerto Rican attorney, made history at oral argument by expressly calling on the Supreme Court to overrule the Insular Cases. Whether the Justices do so in this case or not, the foundation has been laid for the Supreme Court to finally turn the page on the Insular Cases. Working together, this goal is finally in sight.” Neil Weare, President of Equally American

Washington, DC - Congresswoman Stacey E. Plaskett released the following statement regarding the recent oral arguments before the United States Supreme Court dealing with the Insular Cases:

“Since the early 1900s, the Insular Cases have plagued the United States territories, by establishing for America full sovereignty without full constitutional rights and protections for the territories. Since coming to Congress, I have continuously pushed for territorial equity. The millions of Americans living within territories, including those in my district, are no less American than those living within the fifty states.”

“The Supreme Court yesterday heard the argument to correct the injustice that body made over a hundred years ago. The Insular Cases, decided on racist theories, still cast a dark shadow over our country and its promise of equality under the law even today. During oral arguments in Financial Oversight and Management Board for Puerto Rico v. Aurelius Investment LLC, Attorney Jessica E. Mendez-Colberg stated, ‘when there is a constitutional injury, justice requires a remedy,” that remedy is long overdue.   In Financial Oversight BD.v. Aurelius Investment, the Supreme Court is being asked to decide whether a constitutional provision that ordinarily limits Congress applies when Congress legislates for a territory.

“As the Supreme Court prepares to consider this case, I joined a resolution Chairman Raúl M. Grijalva will introduce this week that rejects the use of the Insular Cases in present and future cases and controversies. I hope my colleagues will also support this resolution.

“Our territorial status is eerily similar to the status of the original 13 colonies to the British government. Today, the unequal footing of the territories in voting power, proximity to the mainland, funding formulas and resources of our country continue to keep the Virgin Islands from becoming all that we can be much as it kept colonial America from realizing its full potential. How can we herald the actions of our Founding Fathers while simultaneously depriving fellow Americans of the same rights those Founding Fathers fought so hard to achieve? Just as the colonists, we are subjected to the laws of an un-representational government. But just as the colonists, we will not stop fighting for the same representation that every other great American enjoys. A people who have made great contributions to this country — including Alexander Hamilton, Denmark Vessey, and Tim Duncan — still do not have equal citizenship. Democracy is not complete.”

###